Skip to main content

Welcome to Good Ol’ Wishy’s! Take a step back in time as you climb up on the bar stools and order your favorite ice cream delight.

Open Seasonally Between April and October.

1PM to 8PM.

After October 12th, please call to confirm hours.

For your safety and ours, we are currently offering window service only. Call or message us on Facebook to reserve our indoor facilities for your event. We can also come to you for small-scale events; let’s talk!

Specializing in creative sundaes, one can choose from the established list of favorites or design your own to satisfy your unique taste. Start with one or two of the thirty-four flavors of Perry’s Hard Ice Cream that is in stock or chocolate and vanilla soft serve from Upstate Dairy, and then create! The possibilities are endless. If you are more of a purist, have a cone, walk around town and visit the other great gems that only Croghan, NY has to offer, such as the Railroad Museum, located next door, and the American Maple Museum just up the street.

Home of the Adirondack size Ice Cream cone (larger than your average cone), we also make Maple Syrup Milkshakes with our very own Schweitzer Maple Syrup, Cold Brew Floats, crafted from our own special recipe Cold Brew and soft vanilla ice cream!

Rootbeer Float
Rootbeer Float
Rootbeer Float

Tag your photos on Instagram with #goodolwishys

Not only is Good Ol’ Wishy’s home of world famous ice cream treats, but they also offer a full-service bicycle shop doing repairs, tune-ups, and stocking all equipment essentials. Good Ol’ Spokes bicycle shop carries the popular line of Giant Bicycles, including road, mountain, hybrid, fat-tire, gravel, and children’s bicycles. If in the area, join us on a summer Tuesday evening group ride and enjoy some of the back road scenery.